So let’s dig in. This passage recounts the chariot competition as part of the funeral games held by Achilles and the Greeks in honor of the fallen Patroclus. Because of the length of the passage, I only provide my English translation. To follow along in the Greek, please use the Perseus Project for Iliad XIII.257-624.
But Achilles asked the people to stay where they were and to take their seats in one big crowd, and he carried out prizes from the ships—cauldrons and tripods, horses and mules, strong oxen, women with lovely girdles, and slabs of gray iron.
These lavish prizes he set before the swift-footed charioteers among them—for first place a girl to take home, one skilled at elegant crafts, as well as a double-handled tripod that held up to twenty-two gallons. For second place he assigned a six-year-old brood-mare, unbroken, still pregnant with a mule foal. Next, for the third place winner he set down an unfired cauldron, equisite work, four gallons in volume, still white as the day it was molded. For fourth place, two talents of gold; and for fifth, a double-handled mixing bowl, also unfired. Then Achilles stood up amid the Greeks and delivered this speech:
“Son of Atreus and the rest of you well-greaved Greeks, the prizes on display here shall go to the charioteers in this crowd. If we Greeks were competing now in honor of somebody other than Patroclus, there’s no question that I would win first prize and lug it back to my tent. For you should know that my horses are far superior in caliber. They are immortal stallions, gifts from Poseidon to my father Peleus, who in turn placed them in my care. But don’t worry, my hard-hoofed horses and I are sitting this one out, since they lost such a fine, glorious and mild-mannered charioteer, who so often would moisturize their manes with olive oil as he bathed them with gleaming water. They too stand and mourn for him, never resting their manes upon the ground, rather standing firm with aching hearts. But the rest of you warriors, line up, whoever among you Greeks has faith in his horses and jointed car.”
So spoke Peleus’ son, and the speedy equestrians convened. By far the first to rise to the challenge was Eumelus, lord of men and beloved son of Admetus, supreme in the art of horsemanship. Up next after him leapt Diomedes, the mighty son of Tydeus. He yoked to his car the stallions of Tros, which he had robbed from Aeneas some time ago, though Aeneas himself had Apollo to rescue him. Up next sprang Menelaus, the yellow-haired son of Atreus, descended from Zeus himself. He yoked a rapid team of horses to his car, a mare named Aethe who belonged to Agamemnon, and his own stallion named Podargus. The mare was a gift to Agamemnon from Echepolus, Anchises’ son, so he wouldn’t have to join the expedition to windswept Ilium, and instead enjoy an idle life at home. For Zeus had blessed him with great wealth, and he resided in the spacious country of Sicyon. Menelaus led the mare under the yoke, and she was really itching for a race. The fourth man to get his fair-maned horses in gear was Antilochus, famous son of lord Nestor, the stouthearted son of Neleus. Drawing his car was a team of fleet-footed stallions born andbred in Pylos; whereupon his father standing close by his side, though well aware of his son’s intelligence, offered some good advice:
“Antilochus, there’s no doubt that from an early age you have been dear to both Zeus and Poseidon, and that they have instructed you in every manner of horsemanship. In that regard there is very little that I can teach you, since you know well how to wheel around the turning-post. But the fact of the matter is that your horses turn out to be the slowest in the running, and I can imagine that proving disastrous for you. But while all the others may have superior horsepower, when it comes to devising more subtle schemes they cannot compare to you. So come now, dear boy, and add to your will to win a panoply of clever stratagems, lest those prizes elude your grasp. Strategy, not brute force, makes the better woodcutter. It’s by strategy that a helmsman navigates a swift ship through buffeting winds on the wine-dark sea. By strategy does one charioteer outmaneuver another.
“But he who puts his trust in horse and chariot alone wheels about widely and wildly, swerving left and right. His team meanders up and down the circuit, and he lacks control. But he who is versed in shrewdness and cunning, though driving an inferior team of horses, always keeps the turning-post in view, executes a tight turn, and never forgets how to rein in his team with those ox-hide thongs, but holds steady and keeps a sharp eye on the driver in front of him.
“Now I’ll point out to you a marker that’s very easy to recognize—you can’t miss it. Positioned over there is a dryed-out tree stump, as much as a fathom from the ground. It was either a pine or an oak tree, but in any case the rain hasn’t rotted it out. Two white stones are leaning against it on either side. It sits where the roads converge, and the racetrack all around it is free of all other obstacles. Either it’s the grave-marker of some mortal man long dead, or it happens to be a turning-post set there by some earlier people, and now it’s godlike, fleet-footed Achilles’ turn to use it for that purpose.
“Your job is to maneuver your horses and car very close to this marker, standing in your well-plaited car, putting your weight ever so gently toward the left side of your team, while goading on the horse on the right with a sharp command, giving him free rein from that hand. That way the left horse should approach the turning-post so closely that the very tip of the hub of that well-wrought wheel may appear to just touch it. But make sure not to scrape any of those stones; your horses might get hurt and you might wreck your chariot—a sure delight to your opponents, but a real shame for yourself. But rather, dear boy, stay aware and keep your guard up. For if you manage to drive past the rest at the turning-post and you keep racing forward, then nobody could catch you with a burst of speed and pass you by, not even if he were driving behind you that swift stallion of Adrastus, the godly Arion, a horse of divine stock, or those of Laomedon, excellent steeds that graze on these very plains.”
So spoke Nestor son of Neleus, and when he had given his son the sum of every manner, he sat back down on that very spot.
At last Meriones was the fifth to get his fair-maned horses in gear. The competitors climbed up into their cars and cast in their lots for position. Achilles shook the jar, and out shot the lot of Nestor’s son Antilochus. After him lord Eumelus obtained his, and next up Atreus’ son Menealus, famed for his spearmanship, and after him Meriones got his spot in the race. Last of all Tydeus’ son Diomedes, though being the best by far, drew the lot for his chariot team. They stood all in a row as Achilles pointed out the turning- post, far in the distance across the level plain. He appointed godlike Phoenix, his father’s old squire, to sit there as an umpire, to keep track of the race’s progress and to give a true report.
And in a flash each driver cracked the whip on his team, lashing the beasts with leather and barking commands with great haste. And they charged at full tilt away from the ships and across the plain. Clouds, if not whirwinds of dust rose up and filled the air beneath their chests, and their manes flew like flags in the blasts of the wind. Now the chariots ride firm over the all-nourishing earth, now they bound through midair. And of course there were the charioteers, standing strong in their cars, hearts beating in their chests in lust of victory. Each was crying out to his horses as they flew across the field in a cloud of dust.
But it was not until the speedy steeds were completing the final lap, coursing back toward the silver sea, that each driver showed his true caliber, his horsepower stretched to its limits. At that point Eumelus, grandson of Pheres, quickly took the lead with his fleet- footed mares, but Diomedes’ Trojan stallions bore up right after them. No great distance separated the two teams. In fact they were so very close that Diomedes’ horses seemed like they could at any point mount onto Eumelus’ car, whose back and wide shoulders grew hot with the stallions’ breath, their heads descending upon him as they soared down the track. And now the son of Tydeus would have either sailed by him or at least tied the race, if it weren’t for the begrudging Phoebus Apollo, who flung the shimmering whip clear out of Diomedes’ hands. Tears of utter frustration flowed from his eyes, for now he saw Eumelus’ mares going much faster than before, just at the point when his stallions were stymied, racing without his lash upon their backs.
Apollo may have cheated the son of Tydeus, but he failed to notice Athena, who with great speed rushed to the aid of Diomedes, shepherd of his people, handed him the whip, and pumped up his stallions with a force of fury. The angry goddess then took off after Eumelus and dashed the yoke of his team to pieces. His mares ran helter-skelter about the track, his chariot pole left wriggling about the ground. Eumelus himself went overboard headlong from the car and landed by the wheel. Skin tore clear off of his elbows, nose and mouth, his forehead crushed above his eyebrows. Tears filled his eyes and choked his swelling sobs. Meanwhile Diomedes turned aside of him and drove his hard-hoofed horses forward, pulling far ahead of the others drivers. For now Athena had energized his stallions and guaranteed him the glory. Driving after him was Menelaus, Atreus’ fair- haired son, and then Antilochus, who called out to his father’s horses:
“Get a move on, the both of you! Give it everything you’ve got, on the double! It’s not like I’m asking you to vie with those stallions up there, those of fiery-hearted Diomedes, seeing that now Athena has turbocharged them and reserved all the glory for him alone. Menelaus’ horses are the ones to overtake with speed. Shame be upon you both if you should fall behind Aethe, who’s but a mare. Amen I say to you—and you bet I’ll make good on this—no more tender loving care will come to you from Nestor, shepherd of men; instead he’ll slaughter you on the spot with razor-sharp bronze, if we should win an inferior prize thanks to your negligence. So get in hot pursuit and pump those legs, fast as you can! As for me, I’ll hatch a plan and think it through, to slip past them at that narrow pass. It cannot fail me!”
Thus he spoke, and the horses, threatened by their master’s commanding words, instantly accelerated; whereupon Antilochus tough-in-battle right away spotted a narrow pass in the hollow track. There was a gully in the ground, where water from thawed snow had collected and eroded away part of the road, hollowing out the whole area. There drove Menelaus to avoid a collision. But up raced Antilochus, turning his hard-hoofed horses aside and off the track, leaning to the side briefly as he gave chase. The son of Atreus was shocked at this, and gave Antilochus a piece of his mind:
“Antilochus, you’re driving your horses like a madman. Rein in your team! The road is narrow here, but soon enough you can pass where it’s wider. Don’t risk a collision with my car or you’ll lay waste to us both!”
Thus he spoke, but Antilochus seemed not to have been listening, as he spurred his team on with the whip and charged onward with still greater speed. As far as a discus flies that a young man lets loose from his shoulder to test his strength—by such a distance did Antilochus pull ahead. But the mares of the son of Atreus fell back, as he relaxed the reins intentionally lest his hard-hoofed stallions collide with Antilochus’ in that pass, overturning their well-plaited cars and sending both men headlong into the dust, all because they were so eager to win. So fair-haired Menelaus chose instead to chastise him thus:
“Damn you, Antilochus! There isn’t another mortal man among us more destructive than you! It’s not true when the Greeks say you have any sense. And come what may, don’t think you will carry away that prize without me as a witness of all this.”
With these words he then called out to his horses and cried, “Don’t dawdle on me and don’t just stand there all brokenhearted. I reckon on the horses up ahead there having not much fight left in their hooves and knees, but not in yours. For both of his horses lack the youth to persist.”
So he spoke, and the stallions, taking fright at their master’s stern commands, picked up the pace and in no time closed the gap between the two teams.
Meanwhile the Greeks watched from their seats in the crowd as the horses flew across the plain in a whirlwind of dust. The Cretan chief Idomeneus was the first to mark out the steeds, since he sat higher up away from the assembly at a lookout point. He recognized a driver’s shouting that he heard far in the distance, and marked out the horse in the lead for its conspicuous appearance. The stallion was all around chestnut in color, except for a round white mark on his forehead that looked like the moon. Idomeneus stood straight up and spoke amid the Greeks the following:
“Friends, chiefs and counselors of the Greeks, is it just me or can you discern those horses as well? I think those are a different set of horses in the lead than at the start, and a different charioteer coming into view. Those mares of his must have gotten fouled up somewhere on the plain, since they had the lead coming out of the starting gate. For I definitely saw those mares shooting around the first turning-post, but now I can’t see them anywhere, and my eyes are scanning the whole Trojan plain up and down. Perhaps the reins slipped out of the charioteer’s hands, or couldn’t keep a firm hold at the turning- post and had some bad luck making the turn. I reckon he wrecked his car at that point and he fell out of it, and that his mares darted off in a fit of madness. But you folks, stand up and see for yourselves, since I can’t make the best diagnosis. But that man seems to me an Aetolian national, that lord of Greeks, the mighty son of Tydeus the horse-breaker, Diomedes!”
At that point swift Ajax, Oileus’ son, delivered some insulting language, “Idomeneus, why must you keep blathering like always? Those high-stepping mares shooting across the plain are still too far away. You are certainly not the youngest of the Greeks by a long shot, nor do you have the sharpest eyes peering out of your head. But still you’re always spewing nonsense. There’s no need for you to be such a windbag, since there are plenty others here better in that regard. Those mares in the lead there are the same as from the very start, those of Eumelus, and here he comes rein in hand!”
The Cretan chief was thoroughly incensed at this and retorted, “Ajax, you’re the best at quarreling, you nincompoop! Yet in everything else you fall behind all other Greeks, thanks to your bullheaded intellect. Now come on, let’s wager a tripod or a cauldron, andlet’s both make Atreus’ son Agamemnon the judge of which horses are really in the lead. That way you’ll learn your lesson and pay the price.”
So he spoke, and swift Oilean Ajax stood right up, enraged, to answer him with some harsh words of his own. And now this conflict of theirs would surely have escalated if Achilles himself hadn’t stood up and spoken the following, “No more of this exchange of mean and cruel words, Ajax, and you too Idomeneus. It’s inappropriate. Anyone acting in such a way can only do ill to another. Instead why don’t you take your seats and watch these horses with the rest of the crowd. They’ll show up here soon enough, keen on victory. Only then should every Greek know for certain which horses take first place and which second.”
So he spoke, and Diomedes came hard by, racing along and still cracking the whip on the shoulders of his team. His swift stallions pranced in the air as they brought their journey to an end, still smiting their charioteer with specks of dust. The chariot, overlaid with tin and gold, glided behind the fleet-footed steeds. The wheels left only faint tracks in the fine dust behind them as the team hastened in flight. He came to a stop in the middle of the crowd, his horses dripping sweat down to the ground from their chests and the backsof their necks. Diomedes leapt to the ground from his gleaming car, then leaned the whip against the yoke. Valiant Sthenelus made no delay, hastily grabbed the prizes for his stout-hearted comrades—the double-handled tripod to carry off and the girl to lead away by the hand. Then he unyoked the horses.
And after him Antilochus, grandson of Neleus, drove in his horses, having overtaken Menelaus more by celeverness than speed. But even so Menelaus drove his speedy steppers close behind him. They were separated as far as a horse is from the wheel when it draws its master in a chariot as it hastens across the plain, the hair at the tip of its tail lightly grazing the tires—so very closely does the wheel speed behind it, so small the space in between as it courses across the field—by such a distance did Menelaus trail the peerless Antilochus. Though at first he trailed him the range of a discus-throw, he caught up to him in no time, since fair-maned Aethe, Agamemnon’s mare, had a surge of positive energy. And if there were a farther distance left for them to the finish line, Menelaus’ team would have sailed by Antilochus and the result of the race would have been beyond a doubt. Next in was Meriones, Idomeneus’ loyal squire, trailing the highly renowned Menelaus by a spear’s throw. His fair-maned stallions were the slowest in the contest, and he himself the slowest chariot-driver. Last of all the rest came Eumelus, drawing his fancy chariot and driving his horses in front of it.
And when the godlike fleet-footed Achilles got a look at him he took pity, and standing amid the Greeks he addressed him with winged words, “The best man drove his hard- hoofed horses into last place. So how about we award him the prize for second place— it’s only fitting. But in any case, Diomedes wins first prize!
Thus he spoke, and everyone there agreed to his suggestion. And now he would have handed Eumelus the brood-mare, since the Greeks were in accord, if that son of great- hearted Nestor Antilochus hadn’t stood up and questioned Peleus’ son Achilles regarding the justice of the matter:
“I will get quite ticked off, Achilles, if you made good on your word. Yes, you’re being mindful of circumstances, but you plan on taking away my prize, all because Eumelus, good man that he is, had a mishap with his chariot and speedy team. Well, he should have prayed to the deathless gods and perhaps he wouldn’t have come driving into last place. But if you really feel sorry for him and are a true friend at heart, then there is still plenty of gold in your tent, and bronze and sheep too, and serving-girls and hard-hoofed horses. So hereafter take your pick of those things and present him with an even better prize, or do it right now even, since all the Greeks here will let you. But I will not give up the brood-mare. And if anyone wants to take a chance at her, then he’s begging for a fistfight with yours truly.”
So he spoke, and godlike swift-footed Achilles smiled with delight at Antilochus, since he was his comrade and dear to him. He spoke to him in answer with fitting words:
“Antilochus, if you’re really asking me to get Eumelus something else from my hut, then I will also made good on it. I’ll give him a bronze breastplate, overlaid with a casting of gleaming tin, which I had stripped from Asteropaeus. It should be worth a lot to him.”
He spoke, and told his dear comerade Automedon to fetch the prize from his tent, who went off and carried it out, then placed it in Eumelus’ hands, who accepted it with pleasure.
But Menelaus was deeply disturbed at these transactions and still ardently furious with Antilochus. He stood up and the herald handed him the staff, whereupon he commanded the Greeks to be silent. Then that man, equal to a god, spoke up among them:
“Antilochus, you had sense in the past, but what a thing you’re doing now! You brought shame on my valor and stymied my horses, thrusting your stallions in front of my team, even though yours were far inferior. But how about this, fellow chiefs and counselors of the Greeks, why don’t you be the judge of us both, a trial without bias. That way none of you bronze-armored Greeks will say, ‘Menelaus overwhelmed Antilochus with lies and made off with the mare, since even though his horses were far inferior, he himself was the better in strength and finesse.’ But even if I had to judge, I declare that no other Greek would hold me in contempt, since my judgment would be fair. So come here, Antilochus nurtured by Zeus, and do what’s right: stand here in front of your horses and chariot, but keep in your hands that pliant whip that you used to drive it this time around. Now take hold of your stallions and swear by Poseidon who holds and shakes the earth that you did not intentionally hamper my chariot by cheating.”
Antilochus, on the other hand, saw sense and gave him this reply, “Be tolerant with me now, king Menelaus, since I’m a lot younger than you and you are my elder and mightier still. You know all the ways a young man can be offensive, since his thought lacks caution, while his wit is slight. So please let your heart be patient with me. I’ll surrender the brood-mare to you, the one I earned. And even if you should ask me now for something else even better from my hut, I would gladly give it to you right away, foster- child of Zeus, rather than let all my days be cast from your heart, and I be a sinner in the eyes of the gods.”
Thus he spoke, and the son of great-hearted Nestor led the mare to Menelaus and placed her in his care. Menelaus’ heart was cheered, as do ears of corn covered in dewdrops when they grow ripe in bristling fields. In such a way was your heart cheered, Menelaus, and your understanding too. He raised his voice aloud and had some apt words:
“Antilochus, now it’s my turn to relent from being so angry, since you were not that thoughtless nor foolish to begin with. But this time your immaturity got the better of your intelligence, so try not to outfox your betters a second time. For no other Greek could have persuaded me as you did now, mainly because you have undergone plenty of hardship and drudgery for my sake, as have your father and brother too. And not only will I give in to your entreaties, I’ll even let you keep the mare, though she is really mine. That way you and everyone else here will know that I am not so high-handed and hard of heart.”
Thus he spoke, and he handed the mare over for Antilochus’ comerade Noemon to lead away, whereupon he snatched up for himself the gleaming cauldron. Meriones took up the two talents of gold, since he finished fourth. But the fifth place prize, the double- handled mixing bowl, was left over. Achilles fetched it from the crowd and brought it up to Nestor. He stood by his side and said:
“Here, take this, old man, and let this treasure be yours, a memento of Patroclus’ funeral. You won’t see him anymore among us Greeks, so I award this prize to you as it were to him. For you can neither box, nor wrestle, nor take part in archery contests or footraces, since old age already weighs heavily on you.”
Having spoken he placed the prize in Nestor’s hands. He received it, and there was much rejoicing.